# Figure 3 from "The effect of droplet coalescence on drag in turbulent channel flows", I. Cannon, D. Izbassarov, O. Tammisola, L. Brandt, M. E. Rosti, Physics of Fluids 2021 # y+ SP0 VOF10a VOF10b VOF5a VOF5b VOF3a VOF3b FT10a FT10b FT5a FT5b FT3a FT3b 1.005206463621221902e+00 9.971340417264689115e-01 8.960203707525030703e-01 9.075481601479312710e-01 9.520715911232855433e-01 9.558057738893530608e-01 9.810815908904541027e-01 9.852790799675248401e-01 1.007061622937917900e+00 1.016586206224310729e+00 1.000463543028240032e+00 9.994992307875841808e-01 1.011667870960287541e+00 1.007444918749007101e+00 1.144556102147128884e+00 1.134787295217205338e+00 1.019630158736924974e+00 1.032017032849241067e+00 1.083476059932410029e+00 1.086865821520754727e+00 1.116497721884501360e+00 1.120624048635252112e+00 1.146033633343537916e+00 1.156822724570213623e+00 1.138576782410419597e+00 1.137454223927196306e+00 1.151333188968024945e+00 1.146497304055889455e+00 1.303223485295714967e+00 1.291320275816833618e+00 1.160235358906326120e+00 1.174134630060292173e+00 1.232913854677593068e+00 1.236460353239148047e+00 1.270492238661985684e+00 1.274977281601005874e+00 1.304026812912123301e+00 1.315997400019899288e+00 1.295624474729195175e+00 1.294230925132392684e+00 1.310149519895825732e+00 1.304569825568383523e+00 1.483886591002585575e+00 1.469256648496545248e+00 1.320121718748962447e+00 1.336322725908350773e+00 1.402799773182541676e+00 1.407114415123146278e+00 1.445550157756358756e+00 1.450911019665485302e+00 1.483562287261008583e+00 1.496137092658685441e+00 1.474134290783686962e+00 1.472126967919659357e+00 1.490676208744944997e+00 1.484100068610967771e+00 1.689594639600618287e+00 1.671426251505411464e+00 1.501857357260023118e+00 1.521264026823530013e+00 1.595843434174861297e+00 1.601617167643279771e+00 1.644458486061684654e+00 1.651270852167356251e+00 1.687455731992887564e+00 1.699158147266241370e+00 1.676939139679745505e+00 1.673560487511271955e+00 1.695783309485545898e+00 1.687745867591224691e+00 1.923819558365541305e+00 1.900987005732659219e+00 1.708315178368710052e+00 1.731884059000267317e+00 1.815071306951759667e+00 1.822998366788981972e+00 1.870328016776467983e+00 1.879158167630021303e+00 1.918829701682990274e+00 1.926675681703828191e+00 1.907196838594003019e+00 1.900981819484196311e+00 1.928672786738144795e+00 1.918350569336465972e+00 2.190514580482238127e+00 2.161439481524769501e+00 1.942690334064778757e+00 1.971299237844284402e+00 2.063842813371909113e+00 2.074469629119993996e+00 2.126608348018322214e+00 2.137883381056171039e+00 2.181070704401306681e+00 2.180319334641094287e+00 2.168369625132983369e+00 2.156784527077036717e+00 2.192867782086722617e+00 2.178826935618846328e+00 2.494180967461371967e+00 2.456590586358469608e+00 2.208505433917934635e+00 2.242849313808779943e+00 2.345836589813977469e+00 2.359531469293282058e+00 2.417064445215689084e+00 2.431069067343658574e+00 2.477768167939541577e+00 2.461814222954173292e+00 2.464187920527631803e+00 2.443175905591306485e+00 2.492188974950742431e+00 2.472024483506416903e+00 2.839943981143013829e+00 2.790471171126093886e+00 2.509587070998663627e+00 2.550400344891041726e+00 2.664985298081893106e+00 2.682212013097633907e+00 2.745707180181119700e+00 2.762775995099928661e+00 2.812570846426181159e+00 2.774399589773752339e+00 2.798571881625630198e+00 2.763236469427440944e+00 2.830679633695020847e+00 2.801245725745066029e+00 3.233639387537881049e+00 3.167256660239889943e+00 2.850023709760108215e+00 2.898158604068216793e+00 3.025413579319014445e+00 3.046829440450332438e+00 3.116721844110291517e+00 3.137278785889500821e+00 3.188960687483182177e+00 3.122969371540813555e+00 3.175488753703975320e+00 3.121243237995295683e+00 3.212468527368974147e+00 3.170411061255731244e+00 3.681911952512488373e+00 3.591044092132151810e+00 3.234027068567816077e+00 3.290392844772629832e+00 3.431248909344352782e+00 3.457647091176942133e+00 3.534256868171198551e+00 3.558729661387638910e+00 3.609988385596087923e+00 3.509033922233567804e+00 3.598798130388268568e+00 3.520197479859471734e+00 3.641566564615887902e+00 3.583001245261810297e+00 4.192327591722072810e+00 4.065526663341193725e+00 3.665684861464641564e+00 3.731127257937801200e+00 3.886332403527815949e+00 3.918565765816585333e+00 4.002119491146926222e+00 4.030845749911371456e+00 4.077875366089189768e+00 3.932479989904031470e+00 4.071860506830113913e+00 3.961502694194533269e+00 4.121573448941991735e+00 4.041329348717123793e+00 4.773501067650688157e+00 4.593520160768186145e+00 4.148658131339260535e+00 4.223914126047435325e+00 4.393819990954658472e+00 4.432812804322439071e+00 4.523341358205830609e+00 4.556535422694792281e+00 4.593623201764876818e+00 4.393656503977301675e+00 4.596951688122405955e+00 4.445858380782752306e+00 4.655160532896235992e+00 4.546526905705271737e+00 5.435241389020933234e+00 5.176317786360579376e+00 4.685673101030640275e+00 4.771318127288520117e+00 4.955585065630907060e+00 5.002311948234038574e+00 5.099555366373709653e+00 5.137222342555463506e+00 5.156619337881601872e+00 4.891695421052987491e+00 5.174653248403711991e+00 4.973237494978360651e+00 5.243283555468543078e+00 5.098618383354209804e+00 6.156662925067750258e+00 5.786495059093322624e+00 5.253141009957083440e+00 5.348976869196905959e+00 5.545879242625156635e+00 5.600873900729570920e+00 5.704026759515152811e+00 5.745654178693163416e+00 5.738982571101337804e+00 5.400421385294947640e+00 5.777229405960478736e+00 5.517050278175639200e+00 5.857782950651389875e+00 5.670219054782696944e+00 7.046646119749284232e+00 6.499484684167621928e+00 5.924090817589927838e+00 6.030639125836191106e+00 6.238843017161446625e+00 6.303551821102628239e+00 6.412102881146614308e+00 6.457209644940034465e+00 6.410415928261470775e+00 5.979208877421289259e+00 6.478207962501127071e+00 6.142125033085990005e+00 6.573672898948093923e+00 6.329618775479776360e+00 8.023507714997704099e+00 7.228406972104986394e+00 6.619977183744594207e+00 6.735822426113171169e+00 6.951323446191737254e+00 7.025806695304697591e+00 7.138125313102277048e+00 7.185246590031630909e+00 7.086991462873953651e+00 6.553586096710776410e+00 7.191173890840332206e+00 6.769890078624749563e+00 7.302357480985960159e+00 6.994093976275319591e+00 9.135789559830788775e+00 7.988563379577414025e+00 7.357535643998549091e+00 7.480932539444101081e+00 7.699112798328293650e+00 7.783250580219945647e+00 7.897606031583763730e+00 7.944941233409810621e+00 7.782515843131990074e+00 7.134333343325534926e+00 7.930679797264225783e+00 7.412867074460557149e+00 8.057818421522704000e+00 7.676395193644911075e+00 1.040226467602233207e+01 8.765636491779497774e+00 8.124952699658793520e+00 8.253432636986909543e+00 8.468971737486937101e+00 8.561866434145084526e+00 8.676368641105939972e+00 8.721740896128251208e+00 8.483872973338675294e+00 7.709303832636353881e+00 8.682290624980870675e+00 8.058446148637038675e+00 8.824060192330749786e+00 8.362447310607199924e+00 1.178296099175548939e+01 9.512407899937530331e+00 8.875841485620556526e+00 9.006397357067267961e+00 9.214294929718825244e+00 9.313855308696686208e+00 9.426747147161691487e+00 9.468125820731316367e+00 9.150119978859935443e+00 8.244874554905077702e+00 9.400255932256650127e+00 8.668582978956015594e+00 9.553225007072121855e+00 9.010883909319593599e+00 1.348625990447532885e+01 1.030501288347012157e+01 9.687427386828931120e+00 9.816836981986858390e+00 1.001155297110747000e+01 1.011532001114375134e+01 1.022473113100389952e+01 1.025979459603327903e+01 9.850762997755536432e+00 8.796239732452290738e+00 1.015728198642475988e+01 9.306341979069459924e+00 1.031757134329055958e+01 9.687766990710887427e+00 1.535583149077904075e+01 1.103566055417787162e+01 1.044885170183082579e+01 1.057376957024271213e+01 1.075250626647814478e+01 1.085628726384453735e+01 1.096097163164198740e+01 1.098867563751534959e+01 1.049294654209749034e+01 9.289764641547389346e+00 1.084990498164731321e+01 9.886391969780731870e+00 1.101204798610440605e+01 1.030195391674130789e+01 1.748457781797250021e+01 1.172315940409368551e+01 1.117693635898839055e+01 1.129406985948297404e+01 1.145557835024848004e+01 1.155442435984702776e+01 1.165350256292610354e+01 1.167346022759193680e+01 1.109628770777968576e+01 9.741523056646435919e+00 1.149616523288643144e+01 1.042613117325827332e+01 1.165601687837745182e+01 1.087206849138893539e+01 1.980531209337217646e+01 1.233477734392879199e+01 1.183456518439792227e+01 1.194106293116100481e+01 1.208679820666701410e+01 1.217548128180326827e+01 1.226910146855414219e+01 1.228189433250462770e+01 1.163398501948858943e+01 1.013366768397723305e+01 1.206567488318477110e+01 1.090194998362283307e+01 1.222120228483610838e+01 1.137378590695111136e+01 2.266829081139744062e+01 1.293931399565478380e+01 1.249489364515402201e+01 1.258623154510964604e+01 1.271751015822279562e+01 1.278875287409778672e+01 1.287766267377907425e+01 1.288305537902852294e+01 1.216737079287064560e+01 1.051605099590001835e+01 1.262277539608259680e+01 1.136946035171750147e+01 1.277330703670445011e+01 1.186631197098176749e+01 2.581074785369384728e+01 1.346314790553458707e+01 1.307678127725512240e+01 1.314971385947481330e+01 1.327093687174461145e+01 1.331945537409425917e+01 1.340633921065649758e+01 1.340420289169659007e+01 1.263263801904502515e+01 1.085377185676173006e+01 1.310111628925089811e+01 1.177565563800924764e+01 1.324768457187007620e+01 1.229441284917385069e+01 2.938883704597631308e+01 1.393350316425596880e+01 1.360828477587866381e+01 1.365858384794678670e+01 1.377429849960225816e+01 1.379556016634622218e+01 1.388376963055914892e+01 1.387263309855996951e+01 1.305793051983246222e+01 1.118075442647462836e+01 1.353078285028638383e+01 1.214846889177568201e+01 1.367278119695147964e+01 1.268793332639301319e+01 3.346294914857892167e+01 1.435632234975396493e+01 1.409362171810949249e+01 1.411618899832038743e+01 1.423187945095292584e+01 1.422339130916260252e+01 1.431656557264965457e+01 1.429378166716250398e+01 1.345543707495235175e+01 1.151982045389114440e+01 1.392483305651556691e+01 1.250290000324600825e+01 1.405771814184426383e+01 1.305979263545370017e+01 3.790449837290378809e+01 1.472638363448611187e+01 1.452162668043883720e+01 1.451199589117969069e+01 1.463415925971462705e+01 1.459632448772926949e+01 1.469681828192979545e+01 1.465970558560209369e+01 1.382868494357045641e+01 1.188133186469842073e+01 1.428361469650658755e+01 1.284382659895582535e+01 1.439783552154577606e+01 1.340877682643598767e+01 4.338382491153292619e+01 1.509850177631761881e+01 1.495031339802815396e+01 1.489991548802242960e+01 1.503681842913949041e+01 1.496897447878477116e+01 1.507648175076054464e+01 1.502206997892841578e+01 1.425221499880453813e+01 1.233104323452261752e+01 1.466781928964733339e+01 1.323177516608329540e+01 1.473994123318822247e+01 1.378884457524199192e+01 4.939803247792140439e+01 1.543563748517900258e+01 1.533538291506326168e+01 1.524138901932097134e+01 1.539864210292254576e+01 1.530592083502657808e+01 1.541707759639557906e+01 1.534628116936436193e+01 1.469635924936624072e+01 1.279046667666839632e+01 1.504678807437607091e+01 1.361712611761349656e+01 1.505576274301848194e+01 1.415108006968198140e+01 5.624597687423123915e+01 1.575912802752815622e+01 1.570200845250744237e+01 1.556124835059705802e+01 1.574178629899679294e+01 1.562846580470709590e+01 1.574207808632357164e+01 1.565542331783581709e+01 1.516477356006386579e+01 1.323223191404916932e+01 1.544189318678323097e+01 1.399269634891680347e+01 1.537897838000750284e+01 1.449702413685276170e+01 6.404323726760858904e+01 1.607845536034120215e+01 1.605611362497798922e+01 1.586667479104626466e+01 1.607242831892420654e+01 1.594253896417831129e+01 1.606088142961865373e+01 1.595826788855883827e+01 1.562893418687245095e+01 1.365900427729202526e+01 1.585115629457693842e+01 1.435665442441636053e+01 1.571619509560196981e+01 1.483106087506986803e+01 7.254371908546055181e+01 1.638659902090168785e+01 1.638649223273461075e+01 1.615014714989684208e+01 1.638333225850529828e+01 1.624136396352126610e+01 1.636870636580396976e+01 1.625045928486613889e+01 1.605639122015399778e+01 1.407471806803438419e+01 1.625480242631700634e+01 1.470838603750155826e+01 1.604181452069215652e+01 1.515385863682827683e+01 8.303035635171097795e+01 1.672568236819483900e+01 1.673534713450490941e+01 1.645107797164113705e+01 1.671727966137299859e+01 1.656881026439694082e+01 1.670478325650099904e+01 1.657447002952245896e+01 1.650445151137816069e+01 1.453696146119390420e+01 1.669679933997568000e+01 1.510671677874030649e+01 1.639855734049385561e+01 1.551610513492529186e+01 9.454067842286713130e+01 1.706184584703167673e+01 1.705996187411873777e+01 1.673625331518065096e+01 1.703505802002168679e+01 1.688713510487907143e+01 1.702935645090535388e+01 1.689267219035502166e+01 1.691870595190679083e+01 1.498643009641716262e+01 1.711805052298990404e+01 1.551208597653272392e+01 1.674819914893883066e+01 1.587179592027440123e+01 1.076466520123732380e+02 1.740270988246322048e+01 1.737332512205573920e+01 1.701127348084020241e+01 1.734791971243904030e+01 1.720083303082533277e+01 1.734934352001702962e+01 1.721699274418786274e+01 1.731181766060052141e+01 1.542433750601369802e+01 1.751931773999393371e+01 1.591347159913389753e+01 1.712445327422397412e+01 1.622188313704016238e+01 1.225694789034871945e+02 1.774011890484455378e+01 1.767161267392385327e+01 1.726745995225920183e+01 1.764882681473186210e+01 1.750228992449189747e+01 1.765043753533838711e+01 1.753825232522748934e+01 1.770167120612083522e+01 1.583611558557431565e+01 1.787919764087987673e+01 1.629085877538966898e+01 1.750886903430292207e+01 1.655860155280281631e+01 1.388381697332315241e+02 1.803623302088188041e+01 1.792808167731970670e+01 1.748984470165175154e+01 1.791601363099200483e+01 1.776235269624214297e+01 1.790559040370076715e+01 1.782663589848358754e+01 1.804692385509505570e+01 1.617535117388471377e+01 1.817941579471209579e+01 1.660850114101340935e+01 1.784700393330614077e+01 1.685686738309941290e+01 1.589080743791088821e+02 1.828422319966933784e+01 1.815882456917506715e+01 1.768255865009021477e+01 1.814879941536845465e+01 1.798133030387053211e+01 1.812048623201601316e+01 1.806720365906441117e+01 1.834890077601174951e+01 1.644778011348014246e+01 1.841898632902163158e+01 1.685489841177786019e+01 1.813321936495465181e+01 1.710349705421335287e+01